A new bombshell might be dropping in General Hospital—Portia Robinson may find out on October 2nd that she’s pregnant.

If so, the real question will be one that’s as old as soap operas themselves: Who is the baby’s father? The rumors swirling in Port Charles point to two contenders—Curtis Ashford or Isaiah Gannon.

Curtis has been Portia’s husband and they’ve had a complicated road lately.

Trust issues and secrets have driven wedges between them. On the other hand, Isaiah has stepped in as a romantic presence just when Portia needed comfort. They’ve shared moments of vulnerability and connection, and the possibility they’ve been intimate makes him a serious candidate.

There’s more fuel to this fire: the show has recently introduced both Dr. Frida Navarro—an OB-GYN—and Britt Westbourne, also an OB-GYN. Their involvement suggests there’s going to be medical storyline weight, and that a pregnancy reveal is being built up with signs and clues. If Portia is indeed expecting, the dual OB-GYN presence hints the writers are preparing for careful storytelling around prenatal care, tests, and likely, dramatic conflict over the paternity.

If this unfolds, Portia will have more than just a test result to face. Her relationship with Curtis could be thrown into turmoil depending on who the father is. If it’s Isaiah, she’ll have to deal with fallout—not only personal guilt but community judgment, betrayal, remorse. And if it’s Curtis, then trust issues and past mistakes may resurface. Either way, Portia finds herself at a crossroads: growing life inside her, but also carrying weighty questions.

The big reveal—if it happens—could upend several relationships. Whether Portia keeps the pregnancy, how Curtis or Isaiah respond, and what secrets are exposed in the process could reshape her story arc. Port Charles should brace for emotional reckonings, unexpected confrontations, and perhaps some very raw confessions.