While grand storylines dominate Port Charles, there’s a quieter question bubbling among fans: Which version of Lulu Spencer is the best one?

The debate spans actresses Alexa McKenzie (a child), Emme Rylan and Julie B. Wright—each brought something unique to the role.
Emme Rylan’s Lulu was sassy, sharp-tongued yet deeply vulnerable.

Alexa’s Lulu was youthful innocence just starting down a path of tragedy. Julie had the original charm, the raw soap-essence that captivated viewers in the early 2000s.

The current episodes, with Lulu facing suspicious truths about Gio Palmieri and her family’s legacy, put the character under renewed scrutiny.

The question isn’t just who played her best—it’s who fits Lulu now.

In the context of the storyline: Lulu’s trust is shaken. When she suspects Gio’s background and the Quartermaine legacy shifts, the character requires the strength of Emme, the innocence of Alexa and the gravitas of Julie.

Fans on forums argue: the current arc demands a depth only Julie had; others say the emotional beats align with Emme’s strengths.
The debate mirrors one key soap trope: characters evolve, actors change—and the audience’s attachment shifts too.

Lulu’s story now intersects with heavy secrets, identity betrayal, trust issues—not just love woes. That demands a Lulu who can navigate trauma and agency.

Ultimately, the question isn’t which actress was the best—but which version resonates now. As Port Charles turns the page for Lulu, the viewers may find their answer as the character redefines herself.

The debate continues because Lulu’s journey isn’t over—and maybe the best version is the one still being written.